Insurance Company in Columbus, OH and Surrounding Areas

Exceptional Insurance Solutions Tailored to Your Needs

Why Choose John W. Neighbarger Insurance Agency?

Choosing John W. Neighbarger Insurance Agency means opting for a wealth of experience and local expertise. Our agency stands out through personalized service where familiar faces handle your inquiries and claims, making for a seamless experience. The extensive knowledge and professional credentials of our team, including CIC and LUTCF certifications, reflects our commitment to excellence.

We offer competitive, comprehensive insurance solutions with free quotes and exclusive benefits from Erie Insurance. Our rate-lock guarantee and guaranteed dwelling replacement coverage on homeowner's insurance provides added peace of mind. Trust us to protect what matters most with dedication and integrity. Reach out to us today to get in on the most optimal coverage and solutions in Greater Columbus.

Our Agency Services

Auto Insurance Service

Our auto insurance policies are designed to offer maximum protection for you and your vehicle. We provide a variety of coverage options to fit your budget and needs, including liability, collision, and comprehensive insurance. With our agency, you can drive with confidence knowing you're well-protected against unforeseen events on the road.

Homeowner's Insurance Policies

Protect your most valuable asset with our comprehensive homeowner's insurance policies. We offer guaranteed dwelling replacement coverage and a rate-lock guarantee through Erie Insurance, ensuring your home is safeguarded against any eventuality. Our team will work closely with you to create a policy that fits your specific requirements.

Boat & Marine Insurance

Whether you own a sailboat, motorboat, or yacht, our boat and marine insurance provides the coverage you need to enjoy your time on the water worry-free. We offer protection against damage, theft, and liability, meaning your investment is fully covered. Trust the expertise of John W. Neighbarger Insurance Agency to keep you afloat.

Life Insurance Services

Secure your family’s future with our life insurance policies. We offer a range of options including term, whole, and universal life insurance to provide financial security for your loved ones in the event of your passing. Our team guides you through the process to find the best policy for your needs.

Business Insurance Protection

Protect your business with our business insurance solutions. As the business insurance company Columbus, OH businesses prefer, we offer coverage for property, liability, and commercial auto, so your business remains resilient against risks. Our team will help you navigate the complexities of business insurance, so you can focus on growing your enterprise.

Claims Process Services

Handling claims efficiently is a key aspect of our service. We ensure a smooth and hassle-free claims process. Our team is dedicated to prompt assistance and support. We guide you through each step to achieve a swift resolution, minimizing stress during challenging times so you can focus on other important matters.

Personalized Customer Service

Life is dynamic, and your insurance needs change over time. We make it easy to update your policy to reflect your current situation. Whether you're adding a new vehicle, upgrading your home, or expanding your business, our team is here to assist you in seamless policy changes.

Pay Your Bill

We offer convenient options for paying insurance premiums. Our flexible payment plans and online systems make managing your policy stress-free. Keeping your coverage active is easy with John W. Neighbarger Insurance Agency, allowing you to focus on what's important.

About Our Agency

Learn more about John W. Neighbarger Insurance Agency's hours, payment methods, and more when you click the learn more button below. We are excited to give you all the details upfront before your first visit at our insurance agency in Reynoldsburg, OH.